Home / Oak furniture / Oak vs Walnut: Choosing the Right Wood

Oak vs Walnut: Choosing the Right Wood

Oak and walnut are the two hardwoods most often compared for furniture, and they are very different woods. Oak is pale, hard and open grained, while walnut is dark, smooth and slightly softer. This guide compares the two on hardness, colour, grain, care and cost, and explains how to mix them in one room.

Summary Verdict

Oak suits rooms that will be used hard and rooms that want a light, natural feel. Walnut suits rooms that want a dark, formal look and a smooth, quiet grain.

Best for

Oak: dining tables, desks and family rooms.

Walnut: sideboards, desks and formal living rooms.

Watch out for

Walnut is softer than oak, so it dents more easily.

Mixing the two woods in one room needs care to avoid a clash.

Hardness and durability

Hardness is measured on the Janka scale, which tests how much force it takes to press a steel ball into the wood. White oak scores about 1360, while walnut scores about 1010, which means oak is roughly a third harder than walnut. In practice, that means an oak table will resist dents and scratches better than a walnut table of the same thickness.

The difference shows in daily use. A dining table in oak will take plates, cups and elbows for years with few marks, while a walnut table will pick up dents more readily, especially from hard objects. Walnut is still a hardwood and it is far harder than pine, but it is not the best choice for a piece that will take heavy wear.

Colour and grain

Oak is pale, in the honey and golden range, with a strong, open grain and visible pores. The grain is a feature, and it gives the piece texture even under a plain finish. Walnut is dark, in the chocolate and coffee range, with a smooth, close grain and a subtle figure that shows in waves and swirls rather than in strong lines.

The two woods age differently too. Oak deepens to a warmer honey colour with light and age, while walnut lightens slightly over time, especially in sunlight, moving from a deep brown towards a lighter, warmer brown. Both changes are gradual, and both are part of the character of the wood.

Cost and availability

Walnut usually costs more than oak, because the trees grow more slowly and the timber is scarcer. Oak is widely available in Europe and North America, which keeps the price down, while walnut is less common and the best boards command a higher price. That difference shows in the finished furniture, where a walnut piece often costs noticeably more than the same piece in oak.

Veneer narrows the gap. A walnut veneer over engineered wood costs far less than solid walnut, and it looks the same from the outside. The same is true of oak veneer. When comparing prices, check whether each piece is solid or veneer, because a solid oak piece and a walnut veneer piece are not a fair comparison.

Oak is the working wood and walnut is the formal wood. Choose oak when the piece will be used hard, and walnut when the piece needs to look quiet and considered.

Cleaning walnut

Walnut needs the same gentle cleaning as oak: dust with a soft dry cloth, wipe spills at once with a damp cloth, then dry. The dark colour hides dust better than pale oak, but it shows fingerprints and water marks more clearly, especially on a polished finish. A soft cloth and a little warm water handle most cleaning.

Avoid silicone sprays and harsh detergents on walnut, just as on oak, because they build up a film or strip the finish. Feed oiled walnut with a suitable wood oil when the surface looks dry, and wax a waxed piece when the sheen fades. The routine is the same as for oak, but the dark colour means marks are easier to miss until they are set.

Restoring walnut

Restoring walnut follows the same steps as restoring oak: clean, repair the structure, deal with dents and scratches, sand with the grain and refinish. The difference is that walnut is softer, so it sands more quickly and it is easier to sand through a thin section. Work with a light touch and check the surface often.

Dents in walnut respond to steam in the same way as dents in oak, and scratches can be filled with a wax stick in a matching dark colour. The finish on walnut is often oil or lacquer, and matching a new finish to an old one is harder on walnut than on oak, because the dark colour shows any difference in tone. Test the finish on an unseen area first.

Mixing oak and walnut in one room

Oak and walnut can be mixed in one room, but the contrast needs care. The pale honey of oak and the dark chocolate of walnut are far apart, so a room with equal amounts of both can look split in two. The safest approach is to make one wood the main feature and use the other sparingly, for example an oak dining table with walnut chairs, or a walnut sideboard in a room of oak furniture.

Link the two woods with a third element, such as a rug, a fabric or a metal that sits between them in tone. A warm grey rug, a brass lamp or a linen curtain can bridge the gap between pale oak and dark walnut, so the room reads as one scheme rather than two. Keep the other colours in the room quiet, so the woods can lead.

Which wood for which piece

For a dining table, a desk or a piece that children will use, oak is the safer choice, because it resists dents and it can be sanded and refinished many times. For a sideboard, a bookcase or a piece that will be looked at more than used, walnut gives a richer, more formal look that suits a living room.

FeatureOakWalnut
ColourPale honeyDark chocolate
GrainOpen and visibleSmooth and subtle
Janka hardnessAbout 1360About 1010
CostUsually lowerUsually higher
Best useHard wearing piecesFormal statement pieces

For a bedroom, either wood works, and the choice is about the mood of the room. Oak gives a bright, natural bedroom, while walnut gives a darker, calmer one. Oak furniture covers the wood in full, including the types of oak and how to care for each one.