Home / Mattress toppers and protectors / How to Choose a Mattress Topper

How to Choose a Mattress Topper

Choosing a topper comes down to a short list of decisions: why you want one, the type, the thickness and how you sleep. Each decision narrows the choice, and together they leave you with a small set of toppers worth considering. This guide walks through the decisions in order, so you can choose on the construction and the fit rather than on a label.

Summary Verdict

Start with the mattress underneath, then choose the type and thickness from how you sleep. A topper is a smaller purchase than a mattress, but it still deserves a fair trial at home.

Best for

Anyone whose mattress is sound but whose surface does not suit them.

Sleepers who want to soften a firm mattress without replacing it.

Watch out for

A topper cannot fix a mattress that has dipped or lost its support.

Thickness and fill affect the feel as much as the type.

Start with why you want one

The first question is why you want a topper. The usual reasons are that the mattress feels too firm, that the surface feels tired, that you want a softer bed, or that a guest bed needs a little more comfort. Each reason points to a different topper: too firm points to a soft topper, tired points to a fresh comfort layer, and a guest bed points to something light and easy to wash.

Before you buy, check the mattress underneath. Strip the bed and look at the surface from the side, and run your hand across it to feel for dips or lumps. If the mattress has a deep dip or the springs have lost their tension, a topper will follow the shape of the problem and will not fix it. In that case, a new mattress is the better spend. Our guide to when to change a mattress explains the signs of a failed core.

Choose the type

The type sets how the topper feels. Memory foam moulds around the body and gives a slow, sinking feeling, which suits sleepers who like to be cradled. Latex is firmer and springier, and it holds its shape well. Feather and down are soft and light, and they give a plush, cushioned feel, though they need regular plumping. Wool breathes well and helps with moisture, and polyester is light and easy to wash.

There is no best type, only a type that suits how you sleep. If you move a lot in the night, latex or wool is easier to turn over on than memory foam. If you sleep hot, wool or latex breathes better than memory foam. If you want the softest feel, feather and down is the choice, though it needs more care. Our guide to mattress toppers compares the types side by side.

Choose the thickness

Thickness typically runs from 2.5 to 7.5 centimetres, and it changes how much the topper affects the feel. A thin topper, around 2.5 to 4 centimetres, softens the surface a little without changing it completely. A thick topper, around 5 to 7.5 centimetres, changes the feel a great deal, and can make a firm mattress feel soft. Choose the thickness from how much change you want, not from the idea that thicker is better.

Your sleeping position changes the choice. Side sleepers often suit a thicker topper, because it gives at the shoulder and hip. Back sleepers can suit a medium thickness, provided the topper is not so thick that the hips sink too far. Stomach sleepers usually suit a thinner topper, because a thick, soft layer can let the hips drop. Our guide to topper thickness explains the range in more detail.

Match it to how you sleep

Your weight changes how a topper feels. A heavier sleeper sinks further into a soft topper, so a thick memory foam topper may feel too soft for them. A lighter sleeper may barely sink in, and find the same topper firm. If you are heavy, look for a denser foam or a firmer latex topper that will hold its shape. If you are light, look for a softer fill or a thinner layer.

Heat matters too. If you sleep hot, look for a topper with an open structure, a breathable cover and a fill that does not hold warmth, such as wool or latex. If you sleep cold, feather and down or a thicker memory foam topper will feel warmer. The room temperature and the bedding you use make a real difference, so think about the whole bed, not only the topper.

A topper is chosen from the mattress underneath, not from the label. Start with what the mattress needs, and the type and thickness follow.

Size, sheets and staying in place

The topper must match the mattress size: a single topper for a single mattress, a double for a double, and so on. Most toppers have elastic straps at the corners that grip the mattress, and some have a skirt that fits around it like a fitted sheet. Check that the straps or skirt suit the depth of your mattress, because they can slip on a deep mattress or a mattress with a slippery cover.

The fitted sheet goes over the topper, and it must be deep enough to fit over both the mattress and the topper. Check the depth of your sheets before you buy, because a thick topper with shallow sheets will pull off at the corners. If you use a protector as well, it should go over the topper, and the sheet depth must allow for all three layers.

FeatureMemory foamLatexFeather and down
FeelSlow, mouldingFirm, springySoft, plush
HeatCan feel warmGood airflowWarm, insulating
Turning overHarderEasierEasy
CareSpot clean, airAir, spot cleanPlump, some washable

Care and lifespan

Check the care label before you buy, because it decides how you will look after the topper. Memory foam and latex toppers are usually spot cleaned and aired, not washed, because soaking them can damage the foam. Feather, wool and polyester toppers are often washable, though they need a large machine and thorough drying. A topper that cannot be washed may not suit a household with children or pets.

A topper lasts a few years, depending on the fill and the use. Foam toppers compress over time, feather toppers flatten and need plumping, and wool toppers settle. When a topper no longer springs back, or it has developed a dip where the body rests, it has reached the end of its useful life. A topper is a shorter purchase than a mattress, and its price should reflect that.

What to check before you pay

Before you buy, check the practical details. Check the size and the depth, and make sure the straps or skirt suit your mattress. Check the sheet depth, because a thick topper needs a deep fitted sheet. Check the care label, and make sure the washing and drying limits suit how you will use it. Check the returns period, because a topper needs a few nights at home to judge properly.

Finally, put the topper on the bed, put the sheet over it, and lie on it for a few minutes. It should stay in place, feel comfortable, and not make the bed feel too high or too soft. If it does any of those things badly, try another one. A topper is a smaller purchase than a mattress, but it is one you will use every night, and it deserves a fair trial.